Content Top Jagged Edge

James A. Garfield House

8095 Mentor Avenue
Mentor, OH 44060

Snapshot


Rating
Media 2 pics
Details
  • Free Parking
  • Touching Not Allowed

This National Landmark is said to be haunted by Lucretia Garfield, the wife of former President James A.Garfield, who turns on lights and sometimes cleans up after work crews.

Nearby Real Haunts

Reviews

was told it was another tour group

heard a woman and possibly two children upstairs, heard the children running possibly playing, the woman talked calmly and sounded very friendly, never saw the other "tour group" once we got the second level, didn't hear them, didn't see them leave, or outside. and the only cars ever in the parking lot were mine, the tour guides, and one employ. three cars, three drivers. no other tour group was there. saw a young child when i was on the main level, wearing a night gown, they were standing on the stairs to the second level. non hostile spirits, warm welcome feeling, nothing in the house had negative vibes, no cold spots or feelings of dread/remorse. Most pleasant encounter I've had.

March 2020

Would Recommend Yes
Presence

There is a presence in the home and there are probably attachments also considering the amount of time the family spent in the home and that the furniture, etc. are all original to the home.

My husband had the experience - dizzy, queasy and a feeling of heaviness.

Neither the President nor his wife died in the house. The President died in Jersey while his wife was in California when she died.

President Garfield's mother did die in the home in 1888. She is buried at Roselawn Cemetery in Solon, Ohio.

The caskets of the President and Lucretia Garfield lie in a crypt beneath a memorial at Lakeview Cemetery in Cleveland, Ohio, along with the ashes of their daughter and son-in-law.

Lucretia's father lived in the home as well but he did not die there - he moved to Portage County, Ohio where he passed in 1897 ... He is buried at Fairview Cemetery in Hiram, Ohio.

There are no other known deaths in the home.

July 2019

Would Recommend Yes
Strong female presence

Went on a tour of the Garfield house in mentor, Ohio . Felt a strong female presence in the house which may it very difficult to focus on the tour. Was immediately drawn to a portrait painting in the entry way of the house. Saw the woman in the painting in the photo out of the corner of my eye sitting upstairs in the Library at a small desk. later in the tour found out woman in portrait was Lucretia Garfield. Also could sense Garfields mother and Lucretia's father in the house. my suspension were correct. All 3 died in the house.

August 2016

Would Recommend Yes

Share Your Experience

Overall Rating *
Click to rate
No caps or profanity
Optional
For verification only, will not be displayed
Have you been to this haunt?
If so, did you have a paranormal experience?
Would you recommend to a friend?

Top

Haunt Owners

Visitors to This Page: 0
Clicks to Attraction Website: 0
Last Edit to Your Listing: Jul 30, 2015
Categories: Real Haunted Houses

All information on this page was submitted to Long Island Haunted Houses and was believed to be accurate at the time it was posted. Please report any inaccuracies here.

© 2011-2026 OhioHauntedHouses.com
Ohio's Halloween Entertainment Guide

Newsletter

Sign up for our Halloween guide newsletter!